So let's take a look at some examples of design that I think are good and bad.
I might be a bit biased with this first one, but I genuinely think it's good. Yes, it's my wedding invitation. No, I didn't design it.
I love the simple, clean, capped text. I love the elegant but not too flourish-ey script font used for the names. I also think the design was great for the actual event described on the invitation. It was at a beach club- the simple reeds evoke the idea of an outdoor, natural setting. The color of the reeds are reminiscent of sunset, perfect for the time stated.
The next example I love is from Real Simple magazine. I'm sure all designers love it. It's pretty much perfection. This is from the "Trends Worth Trying" section of the September 2010 issue.
Love that it's billed as something "unexpected" right there in the subhead. I really loved the shapes used here. The lines within the pieces each influenced how the actual item was shown. The bag- made up of rings- is shown as mostly circular, and even in the profile shot, it appears curved and concave. There's so much texture going on here- color is only used in the text and that's all that's needed here. There was so much potential for this page to be a huge mess with all the interesting lines going on, but the use of a totally clean background and simple layout preempted any problems.
This next page, which really hurts my eyes, is from the September 2010 issue of In Style Magazine. I jus think it's terrible- take a look.
This is really what I thought that Real Simple page above could have turned into if it hadn't been handled so masterfully. What a disaster. Nothing on this page makes sense together, other than as a group of advertised products- whose advertisers apparently hadn't wanted to spend too much to advertise. This is obvious at first glance. A reader might think that it's not worth looking at just because it wasn't worth designing well. Everything is overlapping each other, theres not a cohesive message, this isn't targeted to anyone in particular- therefore it suffers overall. I don't want to look at this anymore, so let's move on.
This last one is a little difficult for me to admit is an example of bad design. Like I said in my previous post, I'm a NYC native. Well, for those of you who are unfamiliar with NYC culture, allow me to introduce you to Dr. Zizmor. He's a dermatologist who has been promising "beautiful, clear skin" on subway ads for over 30 years. I couldn't find a landscape photo that would really do this glorious ad campaign justice, but I hope these pictures help get the idea across.
Why the rainbow? Why the oddly placed testimonial? The totally tragic phone number? We could really go on. It's just not good. But here's the strange part. NYers LOVE Dr. Zizmor. Everyone knows who he is, and everyone loves these ads. So let this also serve as an example of a time where bad design becomes a beloved part of a cultural tapestry. I don't seek to understand it- I've been brainwashed too and my love runs deep.
Hope you guys like these pieces, and don't forget who to call when you find yourself in need of beautiful clear skin.